This webpage provides a historical record of Hearing Board Case Nos. 2017-21-AP and 2017-24-AP.

Case No. – 2017-21-AP – Wine Institute, 425 Market Street, Suite 1000, San Francisco, CA 94105

To consider a petition submitted on September 15, 2017 by the Wine Institute requesting a public hearing pursuant to California Health and Safety Code section 42302.1 for review of Final Authority to Construct No. 15044 issued to Central Coast Wine Services for modifications to its winery located at 2717 Aviation Way, Santa Maria, California. Petitioner is requesting the District Hearing Board review and determine whether the permit was properly issued as it relates to whether requirements for emissions control requirements for reactive organic compound emissions from wine fermentation tanks have been “achieved in practice” and therefore qualify as Best Available Control Technology.

09/14/2017 Petition | Exhibit A | Exhibit B | Exhibit C | Exhibit D | Exhibit E

Case No. – 2017-24-AP – Wine Institute, 425 Market Street, Suite 1000, San Francisco, CA 94105

To consider a petition submitted on October 11, 2017 by the Wine Institute requesting a public hearing pursuant to California Health and Safety Code section 42302.1 for review of Final Authority to Construct No. 15044-01 issued to Central Coast Wine Services for modifications to its winery located at 2717 Aviation Way, Santa Maria, California. Petitioner is requesting the District Hearing Board review and determine whether the permit was properly issued as it relates to whether requirements for emissions control requirements for reactive organic compound emissions from wine fermentation tanks have been “achieved in practice” and therefore qualify as Best Available Control Technology. Petitioner is also requesting this petition be consolidated into Hearing Board Case No. 2017-21-AP, as they are nearly identical.

10/10/2017 Petition | Exhibit A | Exhibit B | Exhibit C | Exhibit D | Exhibit E | Exhibit F

10/23/2017 District Answer to Petition | Exhibit 1 | Exhibit 2 | Exhibit 3 | Exhibit 4 | Exhibit 5 | Exhibit 6 | Exhibit 7 | Exhibit 8 | Exhibit 9 | Exhibit 10

12/13/2017 Stipulation and Order 

01/09/2018 Petitioner Opening Brief | Exhibit 1 | Exhibit 2 | Exhibit 3 | Exhibit 4 | Exhibit 5 | Exhibit 6 | Exhibit 7 | Exhibit 8 | Exhibit 9 | Exhibit 10 | Exhibit 11 | Exhibit 12 |Exhibit 13 | Exhibit 14 | Exhibit 15 | Exhibit 16 | Exhibit 17 | Exhibit 18 | Exhibit 19 | Exhibit 20 | Exhibit 21 | Exhibit 22 | Exhibit 23 | Exhibit 24 | Exhibit 25 | Exhibit 26 | Exhibit 27 | Exhibit 28 | Exhibit 29 | Exhibit 30 | Exhibit 31 | Exhibit 32 | Exhibit 33 | Exhibit 34 | Exhibit 35 | Exhibit 36 | Exhibit 37 | Exhibit 38 | Exhibit 39Exhibit 40Exhibit 41 | Exhibit 42 | Exhibit 43 | Exhibit 44 | Exhibit 45 | Exhibit 46 | Exhibit 47 | Documentary Evidence in Support of Petitioner Petition for Review

02/26/2018 District Response to Brief | Exhibit 1 | Exhibit 2 | Exhibit 3 | Exhibit 4 | Exhibit 5 | Exhibit 6 | Exhibit 7 | Exhibit 8 | Exhibit 9 | Exhibit 10 | Exhibit 11 | Exhibit 12 | Exhibit 13 | Exhibit 14 | Exhibit 15 | Exhibit 16 | Exhibit 17 | Exhibit 18 | Exhibit 19 | Exhibit 20 | Exhibit 21 | Exhibit 22 | Exhibit 23 | Exhibit 24 | Exhibit 25Exhibit 26 | Exhibit 27 | Exhibit 28 | Exhibit 29 | Exhibit 30 | Exhibit 31 | Exhibit 32 | Exhibit 33 | Exhibit 34 | Exhibit 35 | Exhibit 36 | Exhibit 37 | Exhibit 38Exhibit 39 | Exhibit 40Exhibit 41 | Exhibit 42 | Exhibit 43 | Exhibit 44 | Exhibit 45 | Exhibit 46

03/13/2018 Petitioner Reply Brief 

03/13/2018 Public Comment – California Air Resources Board | Technical Support Attachment | Exhibit 1 | Exhibit 2 | Exhibit 3 | Exhibit 4 | Exhibit 5 | Exhibit 6

03/15/2018 Attorney Emails Regarding Public Comment from California Air Resources Board (Attorney for Petitioner, Attorney for District, Attorney for California Air Resources Board)

04/17/2018 District Letter in Response to Public Comment from California Air Resources Board

04/18/2018 Petitioner Letter in Response to Public Comment from California Air Resources Board

04/26/2018 Order of Continuance

06/05/2018 EPA Letter to Santa Barbara County APCD Board of Directors

06/05/2018 Settlement Agreement | ATC Mod 15044 – 02

06/06/2018 Wine Institute Request to Withdraw Petitions | Order of Approval of Withdrawal

06/08/2018 CARB BACT Database Revision Request

02/05/2019 PTO 15044